Structured Settlements vs Annuities: Differences and Similarities

Written By: author image Bara Goldberg
author image Bara Goldberg
Bara Goldberg - Amanda Dobanton Esq. is a General Counsel for Fairfield Funding. She has been crucial to the growth of Fairfield Funding for the past 9 years. Prior to Fairfield, she interned at a law firm in Gwinnett County. Ms. Dobanton received a B.S. in History and Political Science from Brenau University and went on to obtain her Juris Doctorate Degree from Atlanta’s John Marshall Law School. Amanda is currently serving on the Board for the National Association of Settlement Purchasers. Amanda is a seasoned expert in the structured settlement and annuity field.
Reviewed By: Amanda Dobanton
reviewer image Amanda Dobanton
Bara Goldberg - Bara Goldberg - Bara is a seasoned expert in the structured settlement and annuity field, with a successful career in structured settlement factoring. Her experience spans prominent companies such as J.G. Wentworth, Peachtree Settlement Funding, and Liberty Settlement Funding, where she managed substantial marketing campaigns. Constantly updating her knowledge, Bara is committed to providing exceptional experiences and maintaining her position as a trusted professional in the industry.

Annuities are insurance contracts that individuals can purchase voluntarily, often as part of a retirement plan, to receive a stream of income payments in the future.

Structured settlements, on the other hand, result from negotiated legal settlements, typically in personal injury or wrongful death lawsuits, where the plaintiff agrees to receive compensation through periodic payments over time instead of a lump sum settlement.

While structured settlements are commonly funded by purchasing annuities from life insurance companies, not all annuities arise from legal settlements. Structured Settlements and annuities both have different purposes, ownership structures, tax treatments, and regulations surrounding their sale or transfer of payments.

What is a Structured Settlement?

A structured settlement is a negotiated financial agreement that typically results from a personal injury, wrongful death, or workers’ compensation claim. It provides the injured plaintiff with compensation through a stream of periodic payments over time, rather than a lump sum payment.

How Does A Structured Settlement Work?

When a plaintiff agrees to a structured settlement, the defendant or their insurance company typically funds the settlement by purchasing one or more annuities from a life insurance company. The annuity is then used to make periodic payments to the plaintiff over the agreed-upon time period.

The features of a structured settlement include:

  • Origin: Structured settlements arise from legal settlements or court orders, often in personal injury or wrongful death cases.
  • Purpose: The primary purpose is to provide long-term financial support and compensation to the injured party or their beneficiaries.
  • Structured Settlement Funding: Structured settlements are typically funded by purchasing an annuity from a life insurance company, with the defendant or their insurance company making the purchase.
  • Tax Benefits: The periodic payments from a structured settlement are entirely tax-free if the settlement arises from a personal physical injury or physical sickness claim.
  • Customization: Payment schedules can be tailored to meet the plaintiff’s specific needs, such as covering medical expenses, lost wages, or future care costs.
  • Guaranteed Payments: Payments are guaranteed by the financially strong life insurance companies that issue the annuities.

What is an Annuity?

An annuity, on the other hand, is a financial product offered by insurance companies or other financial institutions. It provides a stream of payments to the annuity owner in exchange for a lump sum premium or a series of premiums.

The features of an annuity include:

  • Origin: Annuities are financial products purchased voluntarily by individuals, not necessarily tied to legal settlements.
  • Purpose: The primary purpose is to provide a guaranteed income stream, often for retirement planning or long-term care needs.
  • Funding: Annuities are funded by the individual purchasing the annuity contract from an insurance company.
  • Tax Treatment: The principal invested in an annuity is tax-deferred, but the earnings are taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn.
  • Flexibility: Annuities offer various options for payment schedules, beneficiary designations, and additional riders or features.
  • Investment Options: Some annuities, such as variable annuities, allow for investment in underlying sub-accounts, providing the potential for higher returns but also market risk.

Similarities Between Structured Settlement Annuity and Regular Retirement Annuity

Despite their differences, structured settlement annuities and regular annuities do share some similarities:

  • Regular payments

Both structured settlements and annuities provide a steady stream of periodic payments over a set period of time. 

This feature is particularly valuable for those who have received a personal injury settlement and need a reliable income stream to cover ongoing expenses. By receiving regular payments, recipients can better manage their finances and ensure a consistent cash flow.

  • Customization options

Another similarity between structured settlements and annuities is the ability to tailor them to meet specific needs. When setting up a structured settlement or purchasing an annuity, recipients can choose from various payout options, such as monthly, quarterly, or annual payments, as well as lump-sum payments at specific intervals. 

Additionally, both options can be designed to include cost-of-living adjustments to ensure that payments keep pace with inflation.

  • Financial security

One of the most significant benefits shared by structured settlements and annuities is the financial security they can provide. When used appropriately, these options can help ensure long-term financial stability and peace of mind for recipients. Providing a guaranteed income stream, structured settlements, and annuities can help mitigate the risk of financial hardship due to unexpected expenses or market fluctuations.

  • Tax advantages

Both structured settlements and annuities offer potential tax advantages. Structured settlement payments are typically tax-free under the Periodic Payment Settlement Tax Act of 1982, allowing recipients to keep more of their settlement money. Similarly, annuities can provide tax-deferred growth, meaning that funds within the annuity can grow without being subject to taxes until they are withdrawn.

  • Potential for Lifetime Payments: 

Both instruments can be structured to provide payments for the recipient’s lifetime, ensuring a consistent income source.

  • Funding through Annuities: 

In many cases, structured settlements are funded by purchasing an annuity from a life insurance company, essentially using an annuity as the underlying financial instrument.

Difference Between A Structured Settlement And An Annuity

While annuities and structured settlements share some similarities, there are also several differences between the two.

  • Purpose and origin

Structured settlements arise from legal settlements, while annuities are voluntary financial products. The primary purpose of a structured settlement is to provide compensation since the periodic payment settlement act, while annuities are primarily used for retirement income or long-term care needs. 

  • Funding and taxation

The defendant or their insurance company typically funds structured settlements. Annuities, on the other hand, are funded by the individual purchaser.

  • Flexibility and control

Structured settlements are generally less flexible than annuities, with payment amounts and schedules set when the settlement is established. Annuities offer more flexibility and control, with a variety of payout options and the ability to change the contract in some cases.

Selling Annuity payment vs. selling Structured Settlement

It is generally easier to sell or cash out future annuity payments compared to selling structured settlement payments, which often require court approval for sale or transfer. 

Tax implications

Structured settlement payments are generally tax-free to the recipient, while annuity payments may be taxable depending on the specific type of annuity and how it is funded.

Final Word!

In summary, while structured settlements and annuities share the common feature of providing periodic payments, they differ significantly in their origin, purpose, tax treatment, flexibility, and ownership structure.

FAQs

In most cases, structured settlement payment rights cannot be easily sold or transferred without court approval. This is to protect the long-term financial security of the injury victim. In contrast, annuity payments can generally be sold or cashed out more readily, though there may be surrender charges or tax implications.

Structured settlement payments arising from personal physical injury or sickness claims are entirely tax-free, including the principal and interest earned, under Internal Revenue Code Section 104(a)(2). Annuity earnings, however, are generally taxed as ordinary income upon withdrawal.

Yes, structured settlement funds can be used for attorney fee deferrals, allowing lawyers to defer receipt of contingency fees and associated taxes. This is known as a structured attorney fee and is governed by Internal Revenue Code Section 130.

A market-based structured settlement is a type of structured settlement where the periodic payments are tied to the performance of an underlying investment portfolio rather than a fixed annuity. This can provide the potential for higher returns but also introduces market risk.

Pre settlement funding refers to a cash advance provided to a plaintiff before their case is settled, with the expectation of repayment from the eventual settlement proceeds. This can help an injury victim cover immediate expenses but may reduce the net settlement amount available for a structured settlement.

A structured settlement broker or planner is a professional who assists injury victims and their attorneys in negotiating and structuring the periodic payment terms of a settlement. They work with annuity issuers and settlement funds to design customized payment plans that meet the client’s specific needs.

author avatar
Bara Goldberg Finance Writer
Bara Goldberg - Amanda Dobanton Esq. is a General Counsel for Fairfield Funding. She has been crucial to the growth of Fairfield Funding for the past 9 years. Prior to Fairfield, she interned at a law firm in Gwinnett County. Ms. Dobanton received a B.S. in History and Political Science from Brenau University and went on to obtain her Juris Doctorate Degree from Atlanta’s John Marshall Law School. Amanda is currently serving on the Board for the National Association of Settlement Purchasers. Amanda is a seasoned expert in the structured settlement and annuity field.

Bara Goldberg

Amanda Dobanton Esq. is a General Counsel for Fairfield Funding. She has been crucial to the growth of Fairfield Funding for the past 9 years. Prior to Fairfield, she interned at a law firm in Gwinnett County. Ms. Dobanton received a B.S. in History and Political Science from Brenau University and went on to obtain her Juris Doctorate Degree from Atlanta’s John Marshall Law School. Amanda is currently serving on the Board for the National Association of Settlement Purchasers. Amanda is a seasoned expert in the structured settlement and annuity field.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *