Structured Settlement vs Lump Sum Payment – Which One is the Right Pick for Your Personal Injury Settlement?

Structured settlements and lump sum payments are two different options available to individuals entitled to receive compensation, such as in personal injury cases or lottery winnings.

Should I Take a Lump Sum or Structured Settlement Annuity?

When an individual is awarded a significant sum of money, whether through a legal settlement such as a truck accident, pedestrian accident, construction accident, wrongful death or even medical malpractice, they are often faced with an important decision: to receive the settlement money as a structured settlement payment or a lump sum payment. This choice can have far-reaching implications on their financial future and overall well-being.

A structured settlement involves receiving periodic payments over an extended period, typically for the remainder of the recipient’s life. These payments are designed to provide a steady income stream and are often structured to account for factors such as inflation and potential future medical expenses.

On the other hand, a lump sum payment is a one-time, upfront payment of the entire award amount. This option offers immediate access to the full sum, allowing recipients to invest, spend, or manage the funds as they see fit. However, it also carries the responsibility of managing and preserving the money effectively over time.

The decision between a structured payment and a lump sum payment is highly personal. It depends on various factors, including the recipient’s age, financial goals, risk tolerance, and overall financial situation. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, and it’s important to carefully weigh the pros and cons before making an informed choice.

Pros And Cons Of A Lump Sum Settlement

As discussed above, a lump sum settlement is a single, upfront payment covering the entire settlement amount. This means you’ll receive all of your settlement funds at once and have immediate access to them.

Advantages of Lump Sum Settlements

Immediate access to funds: With a lump sum payout, you have the flexibility to use the whole amount of your settlement money to pay off debts, invest, or cover unexpected expenses.
Control over your money: You have complete control over how you manage and invest your settlement funds, allowing you to make financial decisions that align with your goals and needs.
Simplified financial management: Receiving your personal injury claim in one payment simplifies your finances, as you don’t have to keep track of ongoing payments or worry about the long-term stability of the insurance company responsible for your structured settlement.

Disadvantages of Lump Sum Settlements

No future payments: Once you receive your lump sum, you won’t receive any additional payments in the future. This means you must carefully manage your settlement funds to ensure they last as long as you need them.
Potential for mismanagement: Having access to the entire settlement can be tempting, and it’s easy to overspend or make poor investment decisions, leaving you with insufficient funds down the road.
Tax implications: While personal injury settlements are generally not taxed, any interest or investment income you earn from your lump sum may be subject to taxes.

Pros And Cons Of A Structured Settlement

A structured settlement is an arrangement in which the settlement amount is paid out over time in regular installments. These payments are typically made through an annuity purchased by the defendant’s insurance company.

Advantages of Structured Settlement Annuities

Guaranteed income: Structured settlements provide a stable, predictable income stream over a set period, which can be especially beneficial if you require ongoing medical care or have long-term financial needs.
Tax benefits: In most cases, the payments you receive from a structured settlement are tax-free, allowing you to keep more of your settlement money.
Protection against mismanagement: With a structured settlement, you’re less likely to spend your settlement funds too quickly or make poor investment decisions, as you’ll receive small, regular income over time.

Disadvantages of Structured Settlements

Lack of flexibility: Once you agree to a structured settlement, you typically can’t negotiate the terms of the agreement or access your funds early without incurring significant penalties.
Inflation risks: Over time, inflation can erode the purchasing power of your structured settlement payments, potentially leaving you with less money than you anticipated.
Dependence on the insurance company: Your structured settlement payments are only as secure as the insurance company responsible for making them. If the company goes bankrupt or becomes insolvent, your payments may be at risk.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between a Lump Sum and Structured Settlement

When deciding between a lump sum and a structured settlement, there are several factors to consider:

Your current financial situation: A lump sum may be more appropriate if you have significant debts or immediate expenses. However, a structured settlement may be the better choice if you have ongoing medical needs or require long-term financial stability.
Your ability to manage money: Be honest with yourself about your ability to manage a large sum of money. A structured settlement may provide a safer option if you’re not confident in your money management skills.
Your long-term goals: Consider your future financial needs and goals. A structured settlement can provide a reliable income stream to help you meet those goals, while a lump sum may offer more flexibility and the potential for higher returns through investments.
Tax implications: Consult with a tax professional to understand the potential tax consequences of each option and how they may impact your financial situation.

How To Choose Between A Structured Settlement Or A Lumpsum – Examples

To better understand the differences between lump sum and structured settlements, let’s look at a couple of real-life personal injury cases.

Example 1: Jennifer’s Story

Jennifer was injured in a car accident and received a settlement of $500,000. She had significant medical bills and credit card debt, and she wanted to pay off those balances as quickly as possible. Jennifer also planned to invest the remaining settlement funds to generate additional income. After consulting with her personal injury attorney and a financial advisor, Jennifer chose a lump sum settlement to give her the flexibility to pay off her debts and invest the rest of her settlement money.

Example 2: Michael’s Story

Michael suffered a severe spinal cord injury at work and required ongoing medical care. His personal injury settlement totaled $1 million. Michael knew he would need a reliable source of income to cover his ongoing medical expenses and provide him with financial security in the long run. After discussing his options with his injury attorney, Michael opted for a structured settlement that would provide him with monthly payments over the next 20 years, ensuring a stable income stream to meet his needs.

Hybrid Settlements: A Combination of Lump Sum and Structured Payments

Sometimes, a hybrid settlement that combines a lump sum and structured payments may be the best option. This approach allows the injured party to access a portion of their settlement funds immediately while still receiving the benefits of a structured settlement.

For example, you might negotiate a settlement agreement that provides a lump sum to cover immediate expenses, such as medical bills or debt repayment, and a structured settlement to provide ongoing income for future needs.

Selling Structured Settlement Payments for a Lump Sum

In some cases, even if you initially opted for a structured settlement fund, you may find yourself in a situation where you need immediate access to a larger sum of money. When this happens, you might consider selling your future structured settlement payments for a lump sum.

Why People Sell Structured Settlements?

There are various reasons why you might think about selling your structured settlement payment rights:

Unexpected expenses: If you’re faced with a significant, unexpected expense, such as a medical emergency or a necessary home repair, selling your future payments can provide you with the funds you need to cover these costs.
Investment opportunities: If you come across a promising investment opportunity that requires a substantial upfront investment, selling your structured settlement payments can give you the capital you need to take advantage of the opportunity.
Lifestyle changes: Major life events, such as getting married, starting a family, or purchasing a home, may require more financial resources than your current structured settlement provides. Selling your payments can help you access the money you need to make these dreams a reality.

Process and Implications of Selling Future Payments

If you decide to sell your structured settlement payments, you’ll need to work with a company that specializes in purchasing these payments. The process typically involves the following steps:

Requesting a quote: You’ll provide the purchasing company with information about your structured settlement, including the total amount, payment frequency, and duration. The company will then offer you a lump sum quote in exchange for your future payments.
Reviewing and accepting the offer: If you accept the quote, you’ll sign an agreement with the purchasing company that outlines the terms of the sale.
Court approval: In most cases, the sale of structured settlement payments must be approved by a court to ensure that the transaction is in your best interest. Your attorney can help you navigate this process.
Receiving your funds: Once the court approves the sale, the purchasing company will provide you with your lump sum payment, and your future structured settlement payments will be redirected to the company.

It’s important to note that selling your structured settlement payments will typically result in receiving less money overall than if you had continued receiving the payments as originally scheduled. This is because the purchasing company is essentially buying your future payments at a discounted rate to make a profit.

Importance of Choosing a Reputable Structured Settlement Buyer Or A Factoring Company

When considering selling your structured settlement payments, working with a reputable and experienced purchasing company is crucial. Look for a company that:

Is transparent about the process and fees: The company should clearly explain the terms of the sale, including any fees or charges, and provide you with a written agreement that outlines all the details.
Has a proven track record: Research the company’s history and reputation, looking for customer reviews and ratings from trusted sources.
Offers competitive rates: Compare quotes from multiple companies to ensure you’re getting a fair deal for your structured settlement payments.
Provides excellent customer service: The company should be responsive to your questions and concerns and guide you through the selling process with professionalism and care.

By choosing a reputable buyer and carefully considering the implications of selling your structured settlement payments, you can make an informed decision that best serves your financial needs and goals.

The Role of a Personal Injury Attorney

Navigating the complexities of personal injury settlements requires working with an experienced attorney. Your attorney can help you understand your options, negotiate with the insurance company, and ensure that your rights and interests are protected throughout the settlement process.

Additionally, your attorney can connect you with financial professionals who can provide guidance on how to manage your settlement funds and make the most of your lump sum or structured settlement.

Tax Implications

When it comes to personal injury settlements, it’s crucial to understand the potential tax consequences:

Settlement funds are generally not taxed, as they’re meant to compensate you for losses rather than increase your wealth. However, there are exceptions, such as punitive damages, which may be taxable.
Profits from investing settlement money, such as interest or capital gains, may be subject to taxation.
Consulting with a tax professional is essential to understand the specific tax implications of your settlement, plan for future tax obligations, optimize your investment strategy, and navigate complex tax situations.

By working with a qualified tax expert, you can make informed decisions about your personal injury settlement and minimize your tax burden.

Which Type of Settlement is Right for You?

Choosing between a lump sum and a structured settlement due to a personal injury case or as workers’ compensation, is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of your unique circumstances and financial goals. By understanding the pros and cons of each option and consulting with experienced professionals, you can make an informed choice that best serves your long-term interests.

Remember, while a lump sum settlement may offer immediate gratification, a structured settlement proceeds can provide the security and stability you need to move forward after a personal injury. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your individual needs, goals, and circumstances.

If you’re facing a personal injury settlement and need guidance on your options, contact a trusted attorney today. With the right support and advice, you can make a decision that will set you up for a brighter, more secure future.

Bara Goldberg Finance Writer

Bara Goldberg - Amanda Dobanton Esq. is a General Counsel for Fairfield Funding. She has been crucial to the growth of Fairfield Funding for the past 9 years. Prior to Fairfield, she interned at a law firm in Gwinnett County. Ms. Dobanton received a B.S. in History and Political Science from Brenau University and went on to obtain her Juris Doctorate Degree from Atlanta’s John Marshall Law School. Amanda is currently serving on the Board for the National Association of Settlement Purchasers. Amanda is a seasoned expert in the structured settlement and annuity field.

See Full Bio